Scottish Labour MPs Criticized for 'Supine' Questions in PMQs
Research reveals that Scottish Labour MPs are criticized as 'drones' for asking Keir Starmer easy questions during PMQs, igniting political debate.
Scottish Labour MPs have recently come under fire, being labeled as “drones” following findings that point to their tendency of asking Keir Starmer relatively easy questions during Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs). This pattern has ignited a fervent debate about the political motives underlying parliamentary inquiries.
A Closer Look at the PMQs Dynamics
Research shows a significant portion of questions from Scottish Labour MPs is centered around devolved matters. Out of the 28 queries raised in the Commons post the last Labour election victory, only 12 were about policies governed by the UK Government. In contrast, 13 questions were targeted at areas under Holyrood’s jurisdiction, with three not relating to political issues per se.
Health and Local Issues Dominate the Queries
Health, a devolved issue under Edinburgh Parliament’s control, emerges as the most commonly addressed topic by these MPs. Other inquiries span local government funding, ferries, and housing in areas where Westminster lacks authority. However, MPs also bring hyperlocal causes to the fore, such as recognition for Glasgow’s anniversary or support for motor neurone disease charities.
Criticism from the SNP and Greens
The Scottish National Party (SNP) has criticized this pattern as indicative of Scottish Labour MPs acting as “nodding dogs” for Starmer, seeking favor for government positions. Pete Wishart, the SNP’s deputy Westminster leader, argues this behavior showcases Labour’s lack of influence on national policies. Similarly, the Scottish Greens argue for Scottish governance independence, stating much of the questioning belongs in Holyrood, not Westminster.
Varied Approach by Some MPs
Though the criticism holds ground, not all Scottish Labour MPs adhere to this questioning strategy. Some, like West Dunbartonshire MP Douglas McAllister, who addressed the dire situation of a detained constituent in India, focus on reserved matters. Others like Blair McDougall concentrate on crucial international issues, such as children’s abduction from Ukraine.
Historical Context of Orchestrated PMQs
Historical perspectives provide insights into this common issue during PMQs. Former Commons speaker John Bercow criticized “attacks, soundbites and planted questions” for tarnishing Parliament’s image. Similar sentiments have echoed through past governments, revealing the long-standing nature of carefully curated parliamentary inquiries.
Scottish Labour spokesperson defends their approach, claiming the sniping is an inability of the SNP to confront their own shortcomings in delivering for Scotland’s populace. This discourse, as argued by critics, must pivot towards tangible improvements in governance rather than playing passive roles in the political arena.
According to inkl, this ongoing debate highlights the nuanced dynamics within parliamentary proceedings and underscores the need for Scottish MPs to prioritize Scotland’s distinct voice and governance.
